Business administration professor and acting director of the Safra Center for Ethics at Harvard, Nien-hê Hsieh believes corporations should use common sense when considering their moral obligations. The UN Ruggie Principles, he recently told Quartz, were meant to create a “kind of minimal floor” for businesses to ponder action or inaction in the face of world events.
For instance, they can ask themselves, are there significant human rights violations. They can ask if they themselves are undermining the functioning of the institutions that are needed for society to function well. And they can ask what it really means to be a member of society as a business. What kind of society does business need or want? How can it help bring that kind of society into being?
Those are all questions posed by Professor Hsieh. He didn’t, however, explain the colloquialism UN Ruggie Principles.
They are, in fact, the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs), which were developed by a man named John Ruggie.
The UNGPs are 31 principles and meant to implement the UN’s ‘Protect, Respect and Remedy’ framework on human rights and business.
Mr Ruggie, himself a Harvard professor, created the framework in 2008 and three years later, presented the UNGPs to the Human Rights Council. He was careful not to frame the debate as “new international law obligations”. Instead, Mr Ruggie said the UNGPs elaborated “the implications of existing standards and practices for states and businesses; integrating them within a single, logically coherent and comprehensive template; and identifying where the current regime falls short and how it could be improved.”
There has been quite a bit of criticism of the UNGPs for neither being prescriptive nor enforceable, but then again, surely corporate entities (just like individuals) must go by their conscience?
That’s something Nestlé did, not too long ago, when it decided to take social responsibility with respect to its supply chain. We’ll consider that next.
Read the others in the series:
Corporate moral philosophy on Russia: Is there such a thing?
Corporate moralism on Russia: Suspended between pragmatism and principle
‘If Ukraine war grinds on, businesses should study UN’s Ruggie Principles’
What’s with Nestle’s move to do the right thing on child labour?